The World Federation One Stop Fiqh
Search
Menu

Ruling 2082*

If a person gives a lesser amount but adds something else – for example, he sells 1 kilogram of wheat and one handkerchief for 1.5 kilograms of wheat – there is no problem as long as he intends the handkerchief to be the item for which he is receiving the extra amount [i.e. the extra half kilogram of wheat,] and as long as the transaction is an immediate exchange (naqd) transaction.4 Similarly, there is no problem if both sides add something extra – for example, one of them sells 1 kilogram of wheat and one handkerchief to the other person for 1.5 kilograms of wheat and one handkerchief – as long as they intend the handkerchief on the one side, and the handkerchief and half kilogram of wheat on the other, to be the items of exchange.

4 That is, a transaction in which there is no lapse of time between the buyer paying for the item and receiving it. This is in contrast to credit (nasīʾah) and prepayment (salaf) transactions.

  • Commentary

    This ruling changed in March 2022. The previous version of the ruling was as follows:

    “If a person gives a lesser amount but adds something else – for example, he sells 1 kilogram of wheat and one handkerchief for 1.5 kilograms of wheat – there is no problem as long as he intends the handkerchief to be the item for which he is receiving the extra amount [i.e. the extra half kilogram of wheat] and as long as the transaction is an immediate exchange (naqd) transaction. Similarly, there is no problem if both sides add something extra – for example, one of them sells 1 kilogram of wheat and one handkerchief to the other person for 1.5 kilograms of wheat and one handkerchief – as long as they intend the handkerchief and half kilogram of wheat, on the one side, and the handkerchief, on the other, to be the items of exchange.”