The World Federation One Stop Fiqh
Search
Menu

Ask an Alim

Should I pray foe him or leave him?

Q:

Three years ago a person proposed and asked me to marry him, I thought he is good for me because we both are Shia and from Syed families. We used to talk over phone and video calls…I fell in love with that person. We had a lot of fights in the past three years because he used to talk to other girls also. So many times he blocked me then he came back to me…I went for ziyarat and prayed everywhere at Najaf, Karbala, Kazmain, Samara and Mashad for him..When I came back the person had changed. He stopped talking to other girls and came to meet me from far away. One month ago we had a fight again and he left me and blocked me and said it’s over but I can’t leave him because he has seen my hair on video calls and this is a big sin…What should I do now? should I do some amaal to get him back or should I leave him????

A:

Al-Salam Alaykum

what I understand from your question is that you are in a toxic relationship with this man. your first mistake is that you trust someone over online chatting without knowing him. Further, you compromised on your Hijab. Then you find out he is not very religious and he does not care about Islamic rules as he talks with other girls, probably not in a good manner and you get upset. going to religious places and Ziyarat would not fix such a problem (talking to Namahram). this kind of problem only would be solved by a strong decision to correct your behaviour and getting help from a good counsellor.

I think ending such a relationship would be the best option as your previous mistakes would not be fixed by continuing them. If he saw you without a Hijab, the best way is to finish meeting with him not continuing that mistake.

for your next suitor, I suggest you be more careful about your duties. And find someone who is following the rules precisely, so you will not regret it later.

Best regards!
Sayyid Madani