The World Federation One Stop Fiqh
Search
Menu

Ask an Alim

Should I marry this girl?

Q:

Assalam o alikum, my question is about relation between a brother and a sister. I have a 23 year old sister and I am 25 years old myself. I am currently engaged to a girl who’s 22 years old and has called me and incest over me kissing my sister on her forehead and hugging her when she was really upset. We had arguments over this for days and nights and it almost made me wanna kill myself to how can she even call me an incest when I truly don’t have any intentions? She’s my sister and I respect her as my sister nothing more. My fiance even said ” go f**k your sister and have kids with her and a lot more haram stuff” my fiance creates arguments over small things and I’ve taken so much stress over the past year or two that I have ended up in a hospital and even for mental health organisations. She had led me to believe I was a crazy stupid person. I truly love her and I want to spend my life with her but she keeps arguing and I take so much stress that sometimes I just wanna kill myself. I’m sorry I’m making this long but my question is, does that make me an incest if I kissed my sister on her forehead and hugged her when she was crying so much because she was upset and I was the only person there to comfort her? Does that really make me an incest? Also, she keeps on threatening to leave me. Wallahi brother ALLAH knows my intentions I really truly wanted to get married to her and start a new life with life, but things have been so hard. Do you think she’s the right woman for me? We have had arguments over these things for over a year now and we have been together for just under 2 years. I know it’s haram to stay in a relationship with a girl but we don’t do anything haram and I want to marry her as soon as possible. Sorry, again I’m making this long. You think she’s the right woman for me? What advice do you give me? And does kissing sister on her forehead make me an incest? Jazak ALLAH khair may ALLAH keep you happy and give you all the the happiness in the world.

A:

Bismihi Ta’ala,

Salam Alaykum,

No, showing affection for your sister in this way is not a case of incest.  I think your fiance is overreacting. She seems a bit jealous of your love for your sister. If she is like this now, imagine how she will be once you two get married.  I can’t say what is better for you, as you know your situation better, but perhaps you can explore other options as far as marriage is concerned. Remember, the time for changes is now. I am sure there are plenty of options out there.

Sayyid Shiraz Husain Agha