The World Federation One Stop Fiqh

Ask an Alim

Shia View on shimr and ibne muljim


Salam Alaykum we often hear the nasibis saying that shimr and ibne muljim both were shia and shias killed hussain can u shed some light on this.


Alaykum Salaam

A the time of Imam Ai (A) the terms Shia and Sunni were not in general use. Even so, these men were not followers of Ahlul bayt (A),
Shimr was a mercenary who fought in one of the regiments of Imam Ali (A) in Siffin, but against Imam al-Husain (A) in Taff
Ibn Muljim was a Kharijite.
The argument that Shias killed Imam al-Husain is spurious; it is contrary to historical evidence and clearly a part of Umayyad propaganda.

Kind regards